Phosphine Resistance Testing

Phosphine gas is a widely used fumigant used to protect stored commodity from insect damage. After 60 years of use and misuse, evidence of insect resistance to phosphine is showing up in many parts of the world. It is believed that ineffective fumigations from low gas concentrations are the driving force that contributes to phosphine resistance. Recent studies have shown that phosphine resistance has increased in both frequency and strength of resistance. Now the use of phosphine is threatened by the development of insect resistance.

Current research is working to identify and understand the extent of phosphine resistance. Knowing the species of insect and its level of resistance can give us a better understanding of the extent of insect infestation and allow managers to make more effective and efficient fumigation decisions. Outlined are three methods to test for phosphine resistance in insects. Each method requires a different number of sample insects, exposure periods and phosphine concentration.

Screening of Phosphine Resistance

The resistance kit by Detia Degesch can be used out in the field by managers or fumigators to do a quick test to determine if insects have the presence of phosphine resistance and take the recommended actions before fumigating.

  • 20 insects
  • 3000-8000 ppm
  • 8-15 minute exposure

Frequency of Phosphine Resistance

Testing for the frequency of resistance identifies the presence or absence of phosphine resistance. The frequency of resistance is determined by the number of insects who survive a period of phosphine exposure. Insect populations that have about ≥ 80% survival are considered to have high frequencies of phosphine resistance and should be tested in a level of phosphine resistance study.

  • 200 insects
  • 20-50 ppm
  • 20 minute exposure
  • Sampled insects vs non-resistant insects (USDA sample)

Level of Phosphine Resistance

Phosphine Resistance Samples

Testing for the level of resistance identifies the concentration of phosphine gas required to kill resistant insects. This will give managers and fumigators the information needed to determine if a higher concentration of phosphine gas is needed or if an alternative fumigant should be used to eradicate insects.

  • 500 insects
  • 20-1000 ppm
  • 72 hour exposure
  • Sampled insects vs non-resistant insects (USDA sample)

When phosphine resistance insects are found some management strategies to eradicate resistant insects include:

  1. Better fumigation practices (better sealing, monitoring, ability to add gas, pressure testing)
  2. Increase phosphine dosage rates
  3. Use of alternative chemicals (alternative fumigants, combination of grain protectants)
  4. Sanitation (clean transfer equipment, clean bins before and after use, cool grain to minimize insect activity and populations)
  5. Continue using phosphine with a plan and strategy to manage phosphine resistance (test for resistance, monitor insect activity)

Phosphine fumigants are threatened by the development of insect resistance. Phosphine can continue to be an effective fumigant if phosphine resistant insects are managed properly. It is necessary to test insects for phosphine resistance and eradicate resistant populations to ensure the sustainability and future use of phosphine fumigants.

Insect samples can be sent to Fumigation Service and Supply to be tested for phosphine resistance. A detailed report will be provided on whether insects are resistant to phosphine and recommendations will be provided on what you can do to eradicate this genetic resistance. Please fill out the Phosphine Resistance Testing Data Sheet and return to Ethan Estabrook.  This information will help give us a better understanding of your specific situation. Contact Ethan Estabrook at e.estabrook@fumigationzone.com for more information.

Click here to see our Phosphine Resistance Testing Poster